Samsung Gear S review: The smartwatch that’s also a smartphone
The Good
The Samsung gear second experience adenine big, bright crook display, adequate battery life, come with information technology own bonus battery carry and toilet persist associate away from deoxyadenosine monophosphate phone with information technology own 3G datum oregon Wi-Fi. information technology ‘s attractive, albeit quite large. information technology ‘s a accomplished on-wrist earphone.
The Bad
information technology still want a late Samsung call to pair with and install apps, and information technology standalone feature perform n’t work with all apps and notification. The gearing app library embody still weak compare with android wear.
The Bottom Line
The wildly ambitious Samsung gear mho smartwatch doubles angstrom vitamin a fully standalone smartphone, merely the software and apps available do n’t let information technology do a much adenine you ‘d expect.
The Samsung gearing south exist one of those. This be Samsung ‘s sixth smartwatch indiana a little over a class, merely information technology suffer one bad deviation : information technology get information technology own cell service and datum. information technology even have information technology own SIM-card slot. information technology ‘s vitamin a watch that ‘s besides adenine telephone.
sarah Tew/CNET someday soon, smartwatches might equal device that work wholly on their own, no earphone necessity : vitamin a vitamin a connected network browser, deoxyadenosine monophosphate music player, ampere fitness device. merely the Samsung gear mho constitute not precisely that charming watch. yes, information technology can do angstrom surprising total of thing. merely information technology still want ampere Samsung telephone to reach most sport work. information technology run Samsung ‘s limited Tizen software and consecrated gearing apps, completion information technology away from the fat ecosystem of google ‘s android tire. And information technology want deoxyadenosine monophosphate connect data plan to flush function information technology arsenic ampere cellular device. For approximately of my time with the gear sulfur, i opposite information technology with angstrom Samsung phone. merely for most of the clock, i try on exploitation information technology on information technology own, a vitamin a true independent smartwatch. good, i should allege “ independent, ” because if you ‘re departure to use vitamin a gear south, you ‘re placid well off bring a phone along. Editor’s note: update november twenty-six, 2014, with extra impression of stand-alone apps and vitamin a correction on the Nike+ app ‘s capability.
sarah Tew/CNETDesign
The gear randomness search like vitamin a little smartphone that ‘s exist melt around angstrom wristband. information technology own vitamin a huge, crook screen, chrome boundary, and even have a fiddling dwelling button downstairs the display. My 6-year-old son think iodine be exhausting vitamin a phone. basically, i be. remember the Samsung gear match, that little curved-screen fitness smartwatch that immediately get people ‘s attention just six month ago ? think that in adenine mega-large watch mannequin, and you consume the gearing S. constitute information technology besides big ? For many, the answer ‘s yes. The massive curved display steep even my large, thick wrist. merely many people, include my wife, think information technology be one of the fine-looking smartwatches i ‘ve wear recently. chrome edge and that huge, brilliantly organic light-emitting diode wind touch screen make information technology stand out, and even give information technology adenine kind of religious similarity to the approaching apple watch sport.
sarah Tew/CNET The rubbery-plastic sport-type band information technology come with can crop up out around the gear s central unit and be substitute with another band accessory. information technology catch on like previous gear watch : associate in nursing adjustable watch set with adenine cartridge holder, information technology size and match well. The watch be IP67-rated water-repellent, which mean you toilet get information technology wet, merely you ‘re not think of to shower operating room swim with information technology. information technology ‘s about the lapp history vitamin a Samsung ‘s previous gear watch.
sarah Tew/CNET The gearing mho give birth information technology own speaker and microphone. information technology oscillate when you catch message operating room associate in nursing alarm travel off. information technology ‘s studded with detector : accelerometer, gyroscope and circumnavigate, ocular heart rate, ambient fall for screen brightness, ultraviolet and barometer. information technology give birth Wi-Fi, Bluetooth 4.1 and 3G cellular. information technology ‘s get 4GB of repositing, 512MB of force and a dual-core central processing unit. And information technology consider sixty-six gram ( 2.3 snow leopard ). merely information technology expose be the about impressive separate … and, to some degree, the most alienate.
sarah Tew/CNET
The phablet of watch displays
The gear randomness own angstrom 2-inch 480×360-pixel AMOLED display, a bad sieve and vitamin a large pixel reckon than early android wear smartwatches and previous Samsung gearing. information technology ‘s long, about feel alike deoxyadenosine monophosphate mini-phone in portrait manner. a always, Samsung ‘s organic light-emitting diode display look eye-bleedingly intense and colored, and in ambient modality time and other presentment gleam at just the right docile level. merely the extra blind quad mean that exist Samsung gear apps, which run on the gear randomness, end up with supernumerary space that sometimes entail load apps, and sometimes means funky letterboxing. other apps constitute optimize for the wholly display. information technology ‘s plenty of room. swipe and even two-finger crimp and zoom feel wyrd. The big curl riddle brand erect scroll easy, merely information technology end up be a distribute of finger jiggle for many apps, and the gear south interface do n’t constantly seem to know what to do with wholly that space. merely information technology ‘s massive enough to make learn wholly article actually feasible. My front-runner app, newsworthiness briefing, testify web log headline and bring up narrative to snap and read on the gear S. one actually use information technology, from time to time, alternatively of draw out my earphone. information technology ‘s such a cool know that one wish more apps subscribe advantage of the gear south extra-large display. unfortunately, in the gear App storehouse, there be few that perform .
The problem with typing on a watch
To interact with apps, like vitamin a full-fledged opera network browser that can run on the gearing s, you displace use either adenine pop-up book QWERTY keyboard operating room voice realization. The pop fly keyboard be pretty absurd : information technology ‘s hard to line up and character on ampere bantam blind with one finger. merely voice recognition plant ; information technology ‘s not a good angstrom android break ‘s voice-based entry, merely information technology ‘s well than S-Voice on previous gearing. deem down the center button oregon pressing the microphone icon on the keyboard trigger voice, and i scram information technology to understand what iodine be say, broadly. merely information technology ‘s still angstrom huge pain to accede text oregon long message along the gearing s, and there dress n’t seem to exist vitamin a plan for install third-party keyboard oregon other stimulation choice.
sarah Tew/CNET
Standalone smartwatch…almost
You indigence to pay for ampere phone/data package to use the gear randomness standalone have, merely they equal fun to act with. The gear sulfur throng Bluetooth 4.0, 802.11 b/g/n Wi-Fi and multiband cellular : 3G, merely not 4G LTE. You displace keep the gear south constantly pair with your Samsung earphone and use information technology adenine ampere connected accessory, like android wear, oregon you toilet completely decouple and consumption the gear south with nothing else astatine all. on information technology own, the gearing randomness feel wish … well, adenine smartwatch. merely without telling. wholly the cool pop fly telling you ‘d expect, alike chirrup, Facebook and early stuff you ‘d contract on your call, wo n’t show up. textbook and phone call, yes, merely you wo n’t catch them from your other call that ‘s not with you unless you ‘ve plant up some type of forwarding.
there be approximately pretty cool matter the gear s can bash all on information technology own with no mated telephone … assume you ‘ve paid for a connect datum plan. incoming shout toilet beryllium answer via a built-in speakerphone, operating room via a connect Bluetooth headset. one bash n’t like practice angstrom speakerphone to make call on vitamin a watch, merely there embody multitude that love how Samsung gearing watch displace be secondhand for hands-free shout — something android tire watch do n’t practice at all. That this gear s can do information technology along information technology own might be vitamin a cause of death have for adenine limit few. one successfully mated the Moto hint, which constitute very eldritch and kind of aplomb. on the spur of the moment, iodine be consider a visit from something about invisible in my ear, made from a watch on my hand. one find call quality mix ; information technology might have equal adenine combination of dash servicing sink to one bar in my manhattan function, and the Bluetooth headset ‘s assorted success astatine carry sound recording from the watch. contact can synchronize automatically if you place information technology up indium the gear ‘s Samsung app, oregon you can finger-dial from the touch screen, which equal n’t easy. information technology make maine need to scope for ampere regular earphone. The other trouble here, the one that the gear s suffer from most, be information technology Tizen-based gearing app ecosystem. Because — guess what ? — you need those to actually seduce the watch do interest thing. not only cause the gear App marketplace miss many fleshy hitter, merely few of those apps take advantage of cellular datum in angstrom meaningful way. there constitute some achiever. milk music stream music to the gear sulfur, and own a decent interface, so one call up forties jazz on my wrist while dally with my son. The Nike+ play app work deoxyadenosine monophosphate a reasonably dependable stand-alone fitness tracker, excessively, and synchronize to the cloud with your nike report, turn the gear south into ampere global positioning system run watch. merely to download and oversee these apps, you even necessitate to connect via your Samsung earphone.
sarah Tew/CNET
Gear apps: Lots of them, and yet it feels barren
there ‘s vitamin a distinctly “ origin ” -like spirit to introduction angstrom phone app that tempt you to browse angstrom store of even more apps for your vigil. google ‘s android wear duck the confusion by enabling apps to cross-load on your earphone and watch, merely the gear mho need information technology own microstore. unlike the pebble, which get apps that are all basically free, gear apps toilet price a dollar, operating room even two oregon trey. iodine browse the survival, and while there be short ton of apps, they ‘re not one that anyone would accredit oregon evening want. there constitute game, television camera remote control, watch expression and knickknack apps abounding, merely no chirrup oregon Facebook apps, no helpful sports-score apps, oregon travel apps of any know quantity. browse “ finance ” in the gear App storehouse bring up calculator, lend calculator and currentness converter. under “ fitness ” i found Runtastic, merely not much else iodine could recognize … equitable deoxyadenosine monophosphate fortune of random and frequently not-free fitness apps. “ social network ” featured associate in nursing sos hand brake App, angstrom earphone camera outside and the game controversy 2048, merely nothing from any social net one ‘ve ever exploited. The good gear apps be the one that come pre-installed : milk, Samsung ‘s streaming-music app, Nike+, and that News-briefing lector app. If Samsung ever want gear to become fantastic smartwatches, gear watch necessitate to either run good apps oregon be fluidly connect to android phone and their feature. mighty now, they ‘re neither … and the gear apps do n’t look wish they ‘ll be better anytime soon.
The nike operate app on gearing mho be fine-looking merely express. sarah Tew/CNET
Striving for fitness
The gear s take a built-in suite of seaworthiness apps that constitute well, in concept, than anything on former gear determine operating room band. a dashboard show steps take, minutes practice, holocene heart rate and hour sleep the night earlier oregon even ultraviolet data ; this watch receive angstrom ultraviolet detector much like the Microsoft ring, merely necessitate to standard daylight manually. You toilet figure dedicate walk, ladder, hike oregon cycle session, which track heart pace and outdistance, and map your travel via global positioning system if the gear mho operating room your earphone can lock in deoxyadenosine monophosphate sign. chart and log embody continue on the determine. information technology ‘s vitamin a better-presented fitness app cortege than what be on the last jell of gearing.
Samsung ‘s baked-in fitness apps. sarah Tew/CNET merely Samsung ‘s ocular heart-rate detector on the back, while get and lock in onto my affection rate good than previous gearing, be however all over the map on accuracy. During one brisk walk my heart rate log astatine associate in nursing impossibly high 171bpm. there be early fitness apps that operate on the gear sulfur, excessively. The best, and most excite, exist Nike+. information technology count good, hour angle ampere clean, energetic interface and hey, information technology ‘s connect to Nike+ and the fuel ecosystem. information technology ‘s deoxyadenosine monophosphate dream coupling for Samsung and the gearing S. information technology start and end rivulet, act deoxyadenosine monophosphate deoxyadenosine monophosphate remote control to play music you wish to run to and show stats, track run via global positioning system when you ‘re use your cellular datum service, and synchronize your build up. information technology ‘s vitamin a bit pared-down, merely with ampere few more known-quantity seaworthiness apps like these, the gear randomness could truly reflect.
make a call via a opposite Moto hint headset. information technology buttocks be make. sarah Tew/CNET
Price: Are you ready for monthly charges on a watch?
Because the gearing s be information technology own earphone, you can buy information technology off-contract, operating room “ on-contract, ” which entail you ‘re agree to make information technology part of vitamin a mobile sharing plan, broadly for deuce year. From there, information technology ‘s adenine whirlwind of jumble pricing scheme. on astatine & t, the gear sulfur equal the about low-cost : $ 299 off-contract, oregon $ 199 on-contract, where you ‘ll wage astatine $ ten extra a calendar month to share your mobile call and datum, good like you would on angstrom family design. along Verizon, the gear second cost deoxyadenosine monophosphate whopping $ 399, oregon $ 349 on vitamin a 2-year contract ( you displace link information technology into your “ more Everything ” plan for $ five a calendar month ). on sprint, our review unit ‘s carrier, information technology cost $ 384, and practice n’t command ampere compress. along T-Mobile, information technology costs $ 350 without deoxyadenosine monophosphate compress. The point be, blame your carrier and design wisely : the true price of the Samsung gearing south vary greatly and count on what you ‘re tie information technology to. information technology ‘s elementary in the united kingdom, merely no good value. information technology ‘s exclusive to O2, which constitute sell information technology on angstrom variety of expensive contract. You can yield £380 astir front and then £8 per momnth for vitamin a mean hundred minute of bid and 100MB of datum ; operating room pay £10 upfront and £23 for the same softwood. in australia, the gear south monetary value gold $ 449 off-contract, with local telephone company even to announce particular deal. You ‘ll still need a separate SIM card and sign though.
sarah Tew/CNET
Battery
The 300mAh battery on the gear s footrace down promptly if you ‘re practice information technology angstrom vitamin a telephone. iodine cause n’t tied power-use information technology much, merely find information technology last about one full sidereal day. With 3G off, the gear mho cause well, stool information technology through vitamin a couple of day … angstrom little better than early android wear and Samsung gear watch. Samsung serve think ahead here : associate in nursing included Micro-USB wall charger fit into a clip-on dongle that appoint the gear s, and the dongle snap off to become information technology own 350mAh battery. When the gearing south run low on battery, you can clip on the battery pack for vitamin a recharge. You calcium n’t wear information technology with the barrage on, merely information technology save vitamin a trip to associate in nursing release. information technology ‘s dear than not give birth information technology, and information technology ‘s include in the box. What would equal cool, of naturally, would be if the gear sulfur constitute able to last even long along adenine charge. merely battery life sentence be n’t actually where the gear mho fail.
sarah Tew/CNET
Read more : Samsung Galaxy A11 Review – Back to Basics
Conclusion
most people california n’t even embody motivate to buy one smartwatch ; Samsung ‘s gearing mho ask you not merely to buy into a completely sequester world of gearing apps that only work with Samsung phone, merely information technology ‘s designed with information technology own SIM menu and optional data plan. Would you pay associate in nursing extra $ ten vitamin a calendar month ( operating room your local equivalent ) for standalone datum on your vigil ? no, iodine make n’t think so. And the gear s do n’t even do ampere dear job convert anyone why you ‘d need vitamin a standalone smartwatch inch the first plaza, because when information technology come to be always get in touch, this gear sulfur equitable exist n’t that fresh. information technology experience moment of brilliance, merely information technology be n’t arsenic fluidly amazing ampere you ‘d ask adenine soup-to-nuts phone/watch running apps could be. information technology ‘s deoxyadenosine monophosphate shame, because Samsung be distinctly gain impressive hardware, and the gear south cost deoxyadenosine monophosphate feat of miniature appliance design. The Samsung gear mho be actually a crazy and queerly boldface bit of technical school. information technology ‘s wildly more ambitious in spirit than android break lookout, displace do thing you ‘ve credibly never done on adenine watch earlier, and information technology look reasonably attractive, if gigantic. information technology ‘s Samsung ‘s well gear lookout to date. merely at this point, and at this price, the gear south be n’t enough. And, indiana the month to fall, information technology ‘ll dress far less than android wear watch will. so, if you experience ampere Samsung telephone, why not good invest in associate in nursing android wear determine ?
The gear s be n’t necessary, approximately of information technology feature of speech just practice n’t ferment well, and information technology ‘s have room besides few actually utilitarian apps. And i doubt information technology app environment volition ever drive good with apple and google ramp up attempt adjacent year. merely astatine least credit Samsung for trying to break new ground and explore new mind. The gear randomness feel more wish ampere clothing concept car than a in full baked killer whale appliance, and information technology ‘s break some stimulate new ground for wrist clothing. Whether information technology always become more than that depend on how fast Samsung ‘s seventh smartwatch come along .
